
What does it mean to be in the right place at the right time? In 2010, during the recession, during post-grads savaging each other for evaporating jobs and the scraps of relationships that give meaning to the empty accumulating hours, it means being the National. And what’s more, this is a band that’s been here before.
Three years ago, Matt Berninger, frontman of the Brooklyn-based indie rock outfit, sang of being “half-awake in a fake empire,” and of course it was true. Boxer, the masterpiece of an album from which that lyric comes, startled listeners awake with its careful attention to American ennui at the decade’s close. Admittedly, there is a certain specificity with regards to that record’s audience, evidenced by references to Citibank and sport coats, but among the indie set, the National resounded like a gunshot in a closed room. Now High Violet, another collection of urgent, melancholy songs, ushers in this next decade.
“It’s a terrible love and I’m walking with spiders,” the first words heard on High Violet, delivered in the by-now-familiar baritone hiding in Berninger’s slim frame. For newcomers, “Terrible Love” is an ideal introduction to the National. Musically, the song’s repetitive guitar squiggles, backlit by Bryan Devendorf’s propulsive drumming, slow-burn through familiar but nevertheless fresh territory arriving at a climax worthy of post-rock acts like Explosions in the Sky or Mogwai. Berninger’s lyrics, ever relying on the repetition of slightly askew phrases, achieve an emotional understanding that neatly avoids sense. The progression from “walking with spiders” to “it takes an ocean not to break” to talk of a “rabbit hole” makes little literal sense, but strange juxtapositions and bizarre metaphors are Berninger’s bread-and-butter. They work in a mysterious way that justifies the acclaim heaped upon the band.
If it weren’t for the perfect swirls of haunted elegance the band locks into, maybe Berninger’s words wouldn’t stand out so much. There lies another juxtaposition: the tightness of the band’s compositions versus the strange, strange sentences sung over top them. The mystery only deepens when, say, Berninger sings of being “carried to Ohio in a swarm of bees” over meticulously arranged piano and drums on “Bloodbuzz Ohio,” High Violet’s first single. But for every ambiguous image there is a piercing admission like “I don’t have the drugs to sort it out,” a particularly devastating line from standout track “Afraid of Everyone.” Collision could be the word for the National’s aesthetic.
Despite the excellence of most of these songs, High Violet does not represent a huge leap forward for the band. Laid side-by-side along and given cursory listens, it would not be immediately clear which record came first, Boxer or High Violet. The clues to the chronology lie in the lyrics. Boxer, as discussed, is a product of the Bush administration – it is no coincidence that the Obama campaign played “Fake Empire” at events till the grooves were worn from the record. How then does High Violet speak to 2010?
“I still owe money/to the money/to the money I owe,” Berninger sings on “Bloodbuzz Ohio,” a strong indicator of the record’s timeliness. He follows this blackly humorous series with, “the floors are falling out from/everybody I know,” seamlessly transitioning into more serious territory. The freefall he alludes to, the endless and absurd accumulation of debts to be paid – this is commonplace now. The unease induced by this permeates the record’s sound – High Violet could make the listener forget the sun can shine.
As he demonstrated on Boxer, Berninger knows when to stray from the explicit airing of concerns. He is too interesting a lyricist to stay obvious. Thus the record’s best lyric, from perhaps the record’s best song, is a fragment: “All the very best of us/string ourselves up for the.” He intones this incomplete thought 8 times over the course of “Vanderlyle Crybaby Geeks,” the record’s final track. What to fill in the emptiness with? Right now, unfortunately, there are too many immediate answers. But the National are intelligent enough to know to end on a held-breath, letting High Violet become timeless.
RS